- Which is Better – A Blade or Mallet Putter?
- What To Look For In a Blade Putter
- The Best Blade Putters in 2021 – The Reviews
- 1. Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter
- 2. Callaway Odyssey White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter
- 3. Odyssey Stroke Lab Versa Putter
- 4. Cleveland Huntington Beach Collection #4
- 5. Pinemeadow Golf Regular Black Zinc Style Putter
- 6. Wilson Harmonized Golf Putter
- 7. PING Vault 2.0 Dale Anser Platinum PP60 Putter
- Final Thoughts
- Related Articles
While mallet putters have become fairly popular many golfers still prefer the more traditional blade design. Modern technology has improved this seemingly simple club and the best blade putters have a lot to offer most golfers. Let’s dig a little deeper.
Which is Better – A Blade or Mallet Putter?
The first step is to be sure you want a blade putter over a mallet putter. There is no right or wrong answer and much will come down to your personal preference and, to an extent, your putting style.
Many traditional players prefer the look and feel of the blade putters that, despite a few advancements, have been the norm since the origin of golf. While materials, weighing, and other features have certainly evolved, the look of a modern blade putter is comparable to those used for centuries.
Mallet putters come in a range of shapes and designs but are generally larger with more body behind the face of the putter. The designs allow for better perimeter weighting and many find them to be more forgiving and easier to use.
Give some serious thought to which style you prefer before committing to a purchase.
This video should give you more insight into the options.
What To Look For In a Blade Putter
There are many reasons people choose a blade putter over a mallet putter. Let’s take a look at the main factors one should consider before making your decision.
The feel of a putter is rather hard to define and varies from person to person. It is related to weight, balance, materials, design and other factors. It is very much a personal preference and some players simply find the feel of one putter better than others.
There is no doubt that some putters have a better design and a grip that fits the hands better. There are face materials or inserts that will create a softer feel for all that use them. Multiple factors come into play.
One advantage of blades is the slim simple design generally offers a better feel than many mallet putters. This is one of the reasons they remain extremely popular.
While forgiveness is generally associated with drivers, irons and other clubs it is also relevant to putters albeit in a slightly different fashion. Forgiveness in a putter refers to how the putt works out when you strike it near the toe or heel. A more forgiving putter will still deliver fair distance and accuracy in these cases.
While blade putters are generally not as forgiving as most mallet putters, some offer a lot more forgiveness than others.
The main purpose of a good putter is to get an accurate and consistent roll. You don’t want any lift or bounce when the ball is stuck as this can lead to a loss of accuracy and control. The design and face of the putter are important. Face milling and face inserts can help with the quality of the ball roll.
A poorly balanced putter is likely to twist as you strike the ball and this will naturally reduce the accuracy and effectiveness of the shot. The positioning of the weighting and hosel will largely determine the balance of the putter.
Many modern putters have a face insert. These will have a direct impact on the feel and delivery of the putter. Some are designed for a soft feel while others deliver a harder roll. Again, this is a matter of personal preference and related to your putting stroke.
The hosel design is again a matter of personal preference. Some will help certain styles of putting. What is important is that you feel confidant and comfortable when you address the ball on the green. There are various hosel designs including the popular offset hosel.
An offset hosel ensures your hands are forward as you address the putt and often promotes a square face that should improve accuracy. Again, there is no perfect answer and much will depend on your putting stroke on what works for you.
The grip on your putter is just as if not more important than the grip on your driver and other clubs. Modern grip designs offer more comfort and allow for an optimized grip for better results. Not only is the design of the grip important but the thickness is also relevant. Some will benefit from a thicker grip while others will find more control from a thinner grip.
As with all clubs and golf equipment, the prices range from highly affordable options to the rather expensive. Big brands spend a lot of money on research and design and often a vast amount on marketing and sponsorship.
They generally use advanced materials and workmanship. That is not to say that great value for money cannot be found. There are quality blade putters to suit any budget.
One factor that is worth considering is the number of times the average golfer uses the putter relative to the other clubs in the bag. As it is generally used way more often it makes sense to spend a bit more and invest in a putter that works well for you. It is one of the easiest ways to reduce your score and improve your results.
Quick Overview: Our Top Picks for Best Blade Putters
|Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 Putter||VIEW ON AMAZON →|
|Callaway Odyssey White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter||VIEW ON AMAZON →|
|Odyssey Stroke Lab Versa Putter||VIEW ON AMAZON →|
|Cleveland Huntington Beach Collection #4||VIEW LATEST PRICE →|
|Pinemeadow Golf Regular Black Zinc Style Putter||VIEW ON AMAZON →|
The Best Blade Putters in 2021 – The Reviews
Scotty Cameron is renowned for his legendary craftsmanship producing some of the most sought-after putters used by professional golfers and amateurs alike.
The Newport 2 is based on a Ping Anser 2 style with square shoulders and bumpers with a plumber’s neck. This model is manufactured from solid milled 303 stainless steel without an insert flow producing a softer sound and feel. This dampens impact by roughly 30% on this Select Newport 2 putter while the sole weights provide better feel and distance control.
A thinner, flatter topline and sharper bumper lines distinguish the Newport from recent Scotty Cameron releases.
Shafts are available in a selection of 33 inches, 34 inches, and 35 inches. A soft Tri-sole design promotes the putter head to sit square to the target line at address. Redesigned plumber’s neck produces improved toe flow while a new socket radius where the hosel neck joins the top line enhances the visibility of the ball and the leading edge at address.
“Performance Balanced Weighting” is offered by the use of Tungsten interchangeable weights for better weight distribution that increases the sweet spot to offset any slight mishit.
2. Callaway Odyssey White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter
- White hot insert improves sound and feel off the face
- Laser milling insert improves consistency
- Weight placement on the face make for more forgiveness whether on the heel or toe
- Alignment aid for better accuracy to the hole
- Different head shapes to select from
- Might not have your preferred head shape
- May feel too soft for some golfer’s taste
Callaway certainly produces some of the top putters on the market, and their Odyssey line is certainly at the top of the market. The White Hot Pro 2.0 Putter is a great showcase as to why they are at the top.
The cool thing about these putters is that there are many different head shapes to choose from and it can almost be overwhelming. You can also choose between a standard grip or a jumbo grip and that makes it an easier decision to look at this putter.
The reviews really do point out how great the putter feels off the face and the sound is just plain satisfying for players.
With over 200 reviews on Amazon and over a 4-star rating, this putter has proven itself as one of the best on the market. We have even included a link for you and urge you to check it out if you are looking at buying a putter in the near future!
While this blade putter is a fair investment most golfers that play regularly will make the sacrifice given the potential performance it offers as well as the sleek and impressive looks.
The Callaway putters have been popular for some time and the Odyssey is the top putter on tour right now. They come in a range of variations but for those that favor a blade design, this is a leading option.
One of the main aspects Odyssey put a lot of effort into is the balance and weight distribution. The first way they did this is with the ultralight Stroke Lab shaft. The graphite shaft allowed them to save as much as 40 grams which enabled them to reposition weight to other areas for improved performance. The shaft is relatively stiff for improved control.
The weight added to both ends of the putter adds to the smoothness and control the putter has to offer. Another area Odyssey has focused on is face technology. This putter features multiple micro hinges on the face for a smooth and consistent roll with a fair amount of topspin. Most find it to offer accuracy and great distance control.
The combination of design, technology, and materials gives it a feel that most golfers appreciate on the green. More consistency and control are bound to result in fewer putts and therefore a better score.
4. Cleveland Huntington Beach Collection #4
- Soft feel
- Accurate and consistent
- Delivers a good roll
- Smart sleek design
- Good sound and feedback
- Customizable lie angle
- No sightlines on the front of the face
- The softness might take some time to adapt to
Cleveland has used precision deep face milling in a diamond pattern to give this putter constancy as well as a soft and pleasing feel. The head is made from 304 Stainless Steel which adds to the precision and feel while also being highly durable.
It certainly does not hurt that this combination of materials and engineering leads to what most consider as a sleek and stylish look. Another advantage of the material is that it allows for customization. One can adjust the lie angle by 4-degrees either way.
The recent advancements made by Cleveland have put them on the map for leading putters and these are a popular option with amateurs as well as professional golfers.
The putter does have both vertical and horizontal sight lines but some players are disappointed that they do not extend to the face front. For many, this is not an issue.
Despite the quality materials, the design and engineering, this putter is highly affordable. For those wanting a blade putter with a soft feel the Beach Collection #4 is a worthy option to evaluate.
Pinemeadow has to win the top prize in the affordability category. This is a good quality blade putter at a rock bottom price. Pinemeadow hail from Portland, Oregon and the have been around since 1985. You won’t see any fancy marketing campaigns or flashy sponsorship deals and this is the main thing that helps them keep costs down.
While they do their own research and development they essentially copy or clone equipment that has already proved to be successful. This is a common practice but something Pinemeadow does particularly well. This putter is a clone of the Ping Classic Style putters.
It has a remarkably similar design and Pinemeadow does not cut costs on material quality. One can expect a very similar performance to the original Ping putter. It is made from a Zink alloy and die-cast. The result is a soft feel and an easy roll.
The putter has a bold and effective alignment aid for improved accuracy. The low profile of the blade also helps in alignment and centering the ball at address. Most users agree that it offers good control. The standard shaft is a steel 125-gram Apollo shaft and Pinemeadow covers the putter with a 1-year warranty.
If you are on a tight budget but want a quality putter that is well designed and well made this is certainly one to look at. While top golfers will probably invest a bit more, this putter should perform well for putters at all levels.
Wilson is a well-established golf equipment brand with more than a century of experience. There is a lot to appreciate about this putter apart from the highly affordable price. It shows you can get a quality blade putter without breaking the bank. This putter looks good, performs well and comes at a great price.
The putter is heel-toe weighted and the face features a polymer insert with multiple micro-injections. This gives it a soft and consistent feel that most appreciate. It has a plumber hosel to help at address and a distinct alignment aid. These should work well to improve accuracy. The majority of golfers find it to be easy to swing and highly forgiving.
The slightly oversized grip is comfortable and effective with a vertical seam. It works well even in the wet. Despite being a budget putter, this will work well for most players at all levels of the game.
7. PING Vault 2.0 Dale Anser Platinum PP60 Putter
- Exceptional forgiveness across the entire face
- Soft pleasant feel
- True Roll technology
- Highly durable
- Comfortable grip
- Magnetic headcover included
- Somewhat expensive
While blade putters are generally not as forgiving as mallet options this a true exception. It is highly forgiving across the entire face of the putter. While it is one of the more expensive options many agree it is worth the investment.
Custom-weighting is another advantage and something that is rarely seen effectively applied in putters. It allows you to dial the putter in according to your specific putting style and strength. For many, it will improve accuracy and distance considerably. This and the other technologies used add to the cost and are there to improve the performance of the putter.
Another feature that makes this putter so effective is the precision-milled face that incorporates Ping’s True Roll technology. This gives it greater forgiveness and consistency. The face is made from 303 stainless steel and offers a good feel and responsive feedback as well as a pleasing sound. This is what we have come to expect from Ping and the Vault 2.0 PP60 does not disappoint.
The various technologies work well together to deliver a customized putting experience that will help many golfers on the green.
The putter has a comfortable grip and comes with a quality magnetic protective headcover.
We conducted extensive research to bring you the very best blade putters in 2021. You should now have a good understanding of what to look for when selecting the ideal option for your needs as well as the details of some of the most popular options available right now.
While they are all great blade putters, one stood out as the best of the best. The Odyssey Stroke Lab Versa Putter is a tour-proven blade putter that works equally well for the average golfer.
You might have to dig a bit deeper to invest in this putter but it offers a great feel and superb consistency and control. It has a great shaft and is extremely forgiving. To add to the performance advantages is also happens to look impressive.
Give some thought to your needs as well as your budget to find the best blade putter for improved accuracy on the green and the resulting lower score each round.
- How to Measure a Putter Length
- The Best Putters On The Market
- The Best Putters for High Handicappers
Nick Lomas is the founder of GolfSpan, an avid golfer, not quite a pro but has over 15-years of experience playing and coaching golfers from all over the world. His mission is to bring the golfing community a better experience then it comes to choosing the right golf gear, and finding the right set up for your game.