Scotty Cameron learned the art of putter development in his garage as a kid and took his craft mainstream in the early 90s. By 1993, his flat stick had already won Bernhard Langer a Green Jacket, and since then, it’s been smooth sailing.
In this post, I pay homage to Mr. Don T and reveal the best Scotty Cameron putter for 2023.
The mallet putters outshone the blades this year, with our average tester reporting greater consistency with the sizeable head. Despite the oversized design, it was commonly found that the feel of the milled face was soft and generated pure roll across the dancefloor.
Can the right Scotty Cameron putter take your game to the next level? Read on to learn everything you need to know.
The 3 Best Scotty Cameron Putters 2023 Edition
|Best Overall||Most Forgiving||Best Blade|
|Phantom X9||Phantom X11||Special Select Newport 2|
|Rating||4 Stars||4 Stars||4 Stars|
Why You Should Trust Us
Golfspan is independent and not pressured by manufacturers to recommend products. We were not paid for the reviews in this article. Our team has over 100 years of golf experience, has spent thousands of hours reviewing golf equipment, and has hand-picked these putters. We may earn an affiliate commission when you purchase something through our retail links.
The Best Scotty Cameron Putter Review For 2023 – Mallet Putters
1. Phantom X9 – Overall Best Scotty Cameron Mallet Putter
- Produces exceptional forgiveness
- Soft feel
- Generates a clean roll across the green
- Provides optimal feedback
- Built for straight strokes
- It carries a premium price tag
- Not built for arched strokes
The Phantom X9 answers the question of what is the best Scotty Cameron putter in 2023. This winged mallet design produced exceptional stability throughout the stroke and prompted consistent roll and a soft feel.
Titleist engineers employed a milled putter face design, which created superior friction at contact to generate excellent topspin on all strokes. In addition, the milled pattern and 303 Stainless Steel Face produced impeccable feedback to help me judge the weight of each stroke better.
The winged mallet design of the X9 bolstered its stability during the stroke, which prevented it from veering offline. This was thanks to the enhanced moment of inertia (MOI) which did wonders to prevent putter face twist and keep it square into contact to start my ball on line.
Next, Scotty Cameron crafted the X9 in 33, 34, and 35-inch lengths to suit a range of heights and postures. Plus, they fitted the club head with adjustable weights to alter your stroke mass if necessary.
The stock grip for the Phantom X9 is a Pistolero Plus which worked for me but may prompt excess wrist movement for other golfers. Finally, the engineers added a single bend hosel to create face balance and perform for golfers with straight strokes.
2. Phantom X11 – Most Forgiving Scotty Cameron Putter
- Highly forgiving
- Carries optimal MOI
- Generates a smooth roll
- Superb feedback
- Performs best for straight strokes
- Expensive putter
- Not built for extreme arch strokes
The high MOI, winged mallet design of the Phantom X11 catapulted it to the front of the most forgiving Scotty Cameron putters. It kept incredibly stable throughout my stroke and possessed perimeter weighting, which placed mass around the clubface for a wider sweet spot.
I enjoyed forgiveness on all strokes due to the enlarged sweet spot, which preserved spin and ball speed. As a result, I produced a smooth roll across the green for improved distance control.
The high MOI added to the forgiveness by resisting twist during my stroke and starting my ball on the intended line. In addition, the milled stainless steel face produced excellent feedback, making it easier for me to feel the impact and judge the weight of the putts.
Titleist engineers opted for a simple but effective alignment aid, a single white line. Although some golfers may require a more robust offering, I found it clear and easy to use.
The Pistolero Plus is the stock grip offering on this putter, which is moderately sized, and better suited to golfers who limit wrist action. Lastly, the stock hosel is a mid-single bend design that keeps toe hang to a minimum and works for straighter strokes.
3. Phantom X7 – Most Popular Scotty Cameron Putter For Straight Strokes
- Reduces arch in your stroke
- Maximum stability through impact
- Forgiving putter
- High-quality roll
- Produced a pure feel across the putter face
- Not desirable for golfers with extreme arched strokes
- Pricey putter
We are back with winged mallets in our best Scotty Cameron putter reviews, and now we focus on flat sticks for straight strokes. The Phantom X7 putter carries ample toe hang to limit arch in your stroke, while the high MOI helps you square your putter face at impact for a straighter putt.
Scotty Cameron fitted the X7 with a mid-single bend hosel designed to increase face balance for less twist during your stroke. In addition, the putter delivers maximum stability to the clubface at contact to help you keep it square and maintain ball speed and spin.
Unlike other Scotty Cameron putters, the X7 does not feature a face pattern but a milled solid face to give it a minimalist appearance. However, despite its reduced look, it produced a clean strike across the putter face and prompted a delicate touch on all putts.
Titleist stuck to a winning formula and opted for the Pistolini Plus as the stock grip. I enjoyed the reduced grip pressure it promotes, and putted consistently with it. However, it may cause some golfers to generate more wrist movement than desired.
The Best Scotty Cameron Putter Review For 2023 – Blade Putters
4. Special Select Newport 2 – Best Scotty Cameron Blade Putter
- Classic blade design
- Produces a clean roll
- Provides more forgiveness than previous blade putters
- Soft feel
- The plumber’s neck hosel suits arch-straight stroke combinations
- Not recommended for heavy arched strokes
The Special Select Newport 2 is among the most popular Scotty Cameron putters for its classic design, superb feel, and quality roll. However, unlike blades from days past, the Newport 2 sports tungsten weights in the sole to enlarge the sweet spot for improved stability and forgiveness.
Scotty Cameron opted for their famed 303-milled stainless steel clubface, which produced a buttery soft touch and sublime feedback. The milled pattern boosted friction for sufficient topspin across the putter face.
Besides its exceptional performance, this putter is a beauty. First, its compact head shape is enough to excite any golf traditionalist. Then you look at its milled face with a Raw Stainless Steel finish and are reminded of a player-preferred finish, the game’s best preference.
Scotty Cameron fitted the Newport 2-blade putter with a plumber’s neck hosel, which excels for those with a combined arch and straight golf stroke. Finally, the Pistolini Plus is the stock grip of choice and works best for those who limit wrist movement during the stroke.
5. Special Select Newport 2.5 – Best Scotty Cameron Putter For Arched Strokes
- Maximum toe hang suits arched strokes
- Produces pure roll
- Classic design
- Delicate feel on all putts
- Features interchangeable sole weights
- Priced at the higher end of the market
- Not made for straight strokes
The blade design of the Special Select Newport 2.5 closes our Scotty Cameron Putters review as the best option for arched strokes.
The small slant hosel and a ¾ shaft offset create the intensified toe hang on this putter.
Although I struggled with the severe toe hang, I appreciated the milled face patterns look, feel, and performance. Like other Scotty Cameron putters, it helped my ball stay on the clubface, prompting consistent topspin and ball speed for superior forward roll.
Added to the topspin and improved distance control was a premium feel I have come to expect from the brand. I also appreciated the added forgiveness produced by the sole weights, which expanded the sweet spot for consistency on off-center strikes.
Next, I could not help but stop and admire the beauty of the construction. The milled surface with the three cherry rings was a joy to lay my eyes on. Lastly, Scotty Cameron stuck with their popular Pistolini Plus grip as the stock option, which suits players with limited wrist action in their stroke.
What To Consider When Purchasing The Best Scotty Cameron Putter
Scotty Cameron offers their golf putters in a blade or mallet design. A blade putter is a classic design. It is known for its exceptional feel and consistent ball roll. It suits players with a straight-arch stroke.
Conversely, a mallet putter is a larger design renowned for a higher moment of inertia (MOI) content. The increased MOI helps the putter resist twisting to keep the putter face square to the target at impact.
In addition, mallet putters typically possess perimeter weighting, which expands the sweet spot to preserve spin and velocity on mishits. As a result, you casually enjoy superior forgiveness and consistency from mallets over your typical blade.
Overall, I suggest high handicappers explore the blades section at the start before venturing into the attractive-looking blades.
Your putting stroke guides your decision on the best hosel and putter face construction. Golfers with straight strokes should stick with a double bend, center shaft, or mid-single bend hosels as they create face balance and minimize twisting.
Next, those producing a straight-arch combination are best positioned for a plumber’s neck hosel. These shafts create an element of toe hang and guide your clubface to a square position at impact for improved accuracy.
Finally, players operating with a super arched stroke should test putters with short hosels that create maximum toe hang.
What Is So Good About a Scotty Cameron Putter?
Scotty Cameron putters are good because they are milled from high-quality 303 stainless steel to offer a soft feel, pure roll, and attractive aesthetics. In addition, their premium materials help them last decades, as some of my friends have found.
Which Scotty Cameron Putter Does Tiger Woods Use?
Tiger Woods uses the Scotty Cameron GSS Newport 2, which is wider from front to back than the Platinum Series Newport 2. In addition, the putter carries a Raw Face which produces a super soft feel for enhanced feedback on the green.
Is Scotty Cameron Part Of Titleist?
Scotty Cameron is owned by the Acushnet company, which owns and operates Titleist. Therefore Scotty Cameron and Titleist belong to and are run by the same umbrella company. The putters are all called Titleist Scotty Cameron.
What Is The Most Sought-After Scotty Cameron Putter?
The Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 is the brand’s most sought-after putter. Tiger Woods has won every major except one while stroking it. Besides Tiger’s success, the putter produces a super-soft feel and clean roll on all putts.
What Is The Best Scotty Cameron Putter Ever?
The best Scotty Cameron putter of all time is the Special Select GSS Newport 2, the putter Tiger claimed 14 majors with. However, the German Stainless Steel version is reserved for the game’s best. This leaves us mortals to stick to Platinum Series Special Select Newport 2.
When we discuss the best Scotty Cameron putters of all time, the Tel3 Newport and the Classic I come to mind. Tiger used the Tel3 Newport in his incredible 1997 Masters victory. Bernhard Langer stroked the Classic I to a green jacket in 1993.
Scotty Cameron is a premium brand of golf putters suited to golfers with deep pockets and folks searching for a long-term investment. Despite their premium price tags, their putters consistently deliver a soft feel, clean roll, and excellent forgiveness on all putts.
While personal preference and your putting stroke will ultimately have the final say, in my case, the Phantom X9 was the best Scotty Cameron putter for 2023. It produced incredible forgiveness, rolled smoothly on most strokes, and prompted a soft, delicate touch on every stroke.
Finally, our Scotty Cameron putters review revealed that the Phantom X9 packed a high MOI content to resist twisting during my stroke. As a result, it rolled straight and clean and consistently helped me drain more putts. Take a closer look at the Phantom X9.
Matt is a seasoned golf equipment writer and sports fanatic. He holds a Postgraduate in Sports Marketing and has played golf for over 28 years.