Golf is a game of tradition, skill, and patience. As any experienced golfer knows, the game doesn’t always reward perfection. Sometimes, even the best shots land in places you don’t want them to—like a divot, that small hole left behind in the turf after a club meets the ground. It’s an unfortunate part of the game, but one that all golfers, from beginners to pros, must accept. However, the question often arises: should you be allowed relief from a divot?
The short answer? No.
The Rule of the Game: Play It as It Lies
The foundational principle of golf is the idea of “play it as it lies.” It’s a mantra that has been a part of the sport for centuries. Golfers are expected to play the ball from wherever it lands, with only specific exceptions—like if the ball is in water or a bunker—allowing relief. A divot is simply part of the challenge. Whether you’re playing stroke or match games, golf isn’t designed to be easy; it’s a test of skill, strategy, and mental fortitude. The terrain of the course can be unpredictable, and while a divot might pose an inconvenience, it’s not something that warrants changing the rules.
It’s easy to imagine that one unfortunate shot—hitting a divot left improperly replaced by a previous golfer—could cost you a stroke or two. It’s happened to all of us. That seemingly good shot can turn into a missed opportunity, leading to frustration. But this is exactly why golf is so captivating. The game often doesn’t reward perfection. Sometimes, a great shot leads to a bad break, and sometimes, a poorly executed shot works out better than expected. This randomness is the essence of the game.
The Rub of the Green: Golf’s Unpredictable Nature
The unpredictable nature of golf is often referred to as the “rub of the green.” This saying is used to describe how the ball’s trajectory can be altered by factors outside of the player’s control, like the terrain, weather, or even an unexpected bounce off a tree. Golf, by its very design, presents these kinds of challenges, and a divot is just another obstacle to navigate. The idea is that every golfer, regardless of their skill level, faces the same inherent challenges. It’s not about being perfect—it’s about adapting and responding to the circumstances at hand.
Golf is a sport where precision and strategy go hand in hand. Whether you’re an amateur or a professional, you’ll encounter times when things don’t go as planned. You might hit a brilliant shot, only for the ball to land in a divot or an awkward lie. And yet, these situations can often lead to greater growth as a player. Being able to think on your feet, adjust your approach, and still execute under pressure is part of what makes golf such a rewarding pursuit.
The Etiquette of Divots: Fixing What You Can
While golfers may not be able to get relief from divots, they do have a responsibility to help prevent them from negatively impacting others. Golf courses are often shared spaces, and it’s vital to practice good course etiquette. Fixing your own divots—whether by replacing the turf or filling the hole with sand and seed—helps ensure that the course remains in good condition for everyone.
By taking a moment to repair your divots after each shot, you’re doing your part to maintain the integrity of the course. Not only does this create a better playing environment for others, but it also demonstrates respect for the game and your fellow players. It’s a simple act, but one that can make a big difference in how the course plays for everyone, especially for those who follow you on the same fairways.
Adapting to Challenges: The Key to Improvement
So, should you get relief from a divot? The answer is clear: no, you should play it as it lies. But there’s a deeper lesson to be learned from this mindset. Golf is a game of constant adaptation. Every time you step up to the tee, you don’t know what lies ahead. Will you hit the fairway or land in a bunker? Will the wind pick up and alter the ball’s flight path? Golf is about dealing with the hand you’re dealt and finding a way to execute your plan despite the challenges that may arise.
Rather than focusing on the idea of relief, golfers should focus on improving their ability to handle these difficult situations. If you’re concerned about playing from a divot, then practice hitting from awkward lies. You might already be comfortable hitting down on a golf ball, but you may still need to adjust your stance for these situations. That’s how you’ll strike the ball cleanly even when the ground beneath you isn’t ideal. Mastering these scenarios will make you a better, more versatile golfer in the long run.
The Bigger Picture
The desire for relief from divots or other course-related obstacles often stems from a frustration with the game’s inherent unpredictability. And while it might seem appealing to make changes to the rules to allow for relief, such shifts can have unintended consequences. Golf has already undergone many changes in recent decades (including the out of bound rule), and not all of them have been for the better.
We’ve seen other major sports struggle with their rule changes—take baseball, for instance, with its ongoing challenges around umpire decisions, or football’s constant tinkering with kickoff rules. Once you start changing the rules in an attempt to make the game easier or more predictable, it becomes a slippery slope. Golf’s appeal lies in its purity and tradition, and as soon as you begin altering the rules, you risk undermining the very essence of what makes the sport so unique.
In many ways, the divot debate is a microcosm of this larger issue. While it’s easy to suggest a rule change when you’re in a tough spot, golf’s challenges are what give the game its character. You can’t always control your outcome, and you can’t always predict how your shots will play out. But that’s what makes golf exciting. It’s a game that forces you to embrace both success and failure with grace.
Conclusion: Embrace the Challenge
In the end, playing from a divot is just another challenge to navigate on your golfing journey. Whether you’re a novice or a seasoned pro, golf will continue to test your abilities, sometimes offering rewards and other times delivering unexpected setbacks. Rather than calling for rule changes or hoping for an easier path, it’s far more rewarding to embrace the challenge.
Fix your divots, adapt to the lies you’re given, and remember that the rub of the green is what makes golf such an intriguing and rewarding game. If you’re looking for predictability and perfect lies, perhaps another sport is better suited for you. But if you’re ready to face the unpredictable with skill, patience, and a positive attitude, then golf will continue to offer you endless opportunities for growth and enjoyment. After all, that’s the beauty of the game.
Check out the video that inspired this article on YouTube. Or visit Golfspan for more resources.
Related: The Best-Ever TaylorMade Drivers
Clint is PGA-certified and was a Head Teaching Professional at one of Toronto's busiest golf academies. He was also featured on Canada's National Golf TV program, "Score Golf Canada," twice. He graduated with a degree in Golf Management from the College of the Desert in California and studied under Callaway's co-founder, Tony Manzoni. He has a handicap index of 6.2 and spends the winters near Oaxaca, Mexico, where he plays twice a month at the Club de Golf Vista Hermosa. He's written over 100 articles at GolfSpan since 2021. You can connect with Clint at LinkedIn, FB, his website, or Clintcpga@gmail.com.
