8 of The Best Golf Balls For The Average Golfer – Which Come Out On Top?

Many golfers play with a variety of the cheapest golf balls that they can lay their hands on. This is an inexpensive way to learn while you are losing a ball on every second hole, but it does not aid you to obtain reliability and consistency.

A variety of balls means differences in construction, compression rate, spin rate, and outer layers. We will review the best golf balls for the average golfer to provide an insight into what is available enabling you to make a decision on the most suitable golf ball for your swing and short game.

The selection of a golf ball is extremely difficult and confusing. We would recommend that you try a few different balls from the trusted brands and look at the different construction before making a final decision.

The average mid-handicap golfer does not require a premium ball with exaggerated sidespin as the ball will tend to go far offline on many of the not-so-good shots.

Golf balls that cater to the average mid-handicap golfer are mostly less expensive and because they are more suitable to your game it will reduce your score. That is a win-win situation for you!

Premium balls used by advanced players and professionals accentuate the spin and any slight mishit could leave you in the rough. A fade can become a slice and a draw can become a hook as a result of the amount of spin.

They also come at a premium cost which does not make financial sense if your ball consistently tracks offline.

You will have to try out several construction types for a few rounds each to determine which ones will suit your game the best. Once you have decided on the type of golf ball it is recommended that you try the same ball in the various brands to get to the optimal ball for your game.

When you have found the optimal ball for your game it is highly recommended that you play with the same brand and type for a period to get used to the ball and to track the improvement in your game. You will be tempted to play other golf balls, but it will be worthwhile to stick to your selection for quite a few rounds.

Let us look at the aspects of golf balls that should play a significant role in your decision before we assess the individual golf balls.

Key Selection Criteria

Accuracy

All golfers are well aware of the role that accuracy plays in reducing their scores and enjoyment of the game. You can improve the accuracy of your shots through practice but choosing the right golf ball for you will aid in your quest for the most accurate shots that you can hit.

Consistency in direction and accuracy results in fewer shots and a lower handicap. Everyone including professional golfers has a few mishits, but you need a golf ball that has a consistent trajectory with every club in your bag.

The construction of golf balls evolved into an almost exact science and research has found that multi-layered golf balls tend to be the most accurate.

Affordability

Unlike most golf equipment that is purchased once-off and then used for many years, a golf ball is a product that has to be replaced very often. If you do not lose the ball they tend to scuff and will need replacement. No golf ball is made to last forever.

The prices of golf balls can vary tremendously between the various construction methods and brands. Choosing the most expensive balls available can make your round expensive if you lose a few balls.

Fortunately, you can control the costs by selecting golf balls to suit your budget and where your game is at. If you know that you are likely to lose some balls in a round, buy a less expensive ball and make sure that you have sufficient stock for the round. If you have selected an expensive golf ball and find that you are losing too many, you can always change to a less expensive ball.

Golf balls can be expensive and typically come in packs of twelve with the price ranging anywhere between $5-50 per dozen. To continue the enjoyment and affordability of golf choose the golf ball that will not make you turn your back on the game due to affordability issues.

Brand

There are many brands of golf balls available and they each have unique characteristics. Some brands have been around for a long time and are recognized in the premium brand category. Others are relatively new to the market but have invested heavily in the research and development of their golf balls. Golfers often decide on a brand that they prefer and stick to it.

The premium brands generally offer the top-end balls used by advanced players and professionals but have an extended range to cater for every golfer.

You should base your decision on the construction type of the ball before selecting a brand that will suit your game. Once you have reached consistency in your golf game you can become more brand conscious. Until then keep an open mind and use the ball that suits your pocket and game.

Construction

The type of construction of the golf ball will play a huge part in the way that the ball feels on the club, spin rate, ball trajectory, and reaction on the green.

To determine which ball will suit your game the best, you will need to evaluate your game and determine which of the properties will benefit your game the most. If you require more feel and spin to improve your short game, you will need a different construction that someone that requires more distance and less spin.

We will provide some more information on the various type of construction and materials here for you to have a better understanding of which ball is more suitable for your playing style.

1-Piece Golf Ball

This is the simplest construction of a golf ball. The ball consists of a single core piece and the outer cover. This is the most suitable construction for beginner golfers and has the least spin of all the various constructions. The simple construction method keeps the cost down and makes it ideal for finding your way into the game of golf.

The 1-piece ball is often used by driving ranges or businesses that prefer durability to the workability of the golf ball.

Once you make consistent contact with the golf ball you should consider moving on from the 1-piece golf ball.

2-Piece Golf Ball

The 2-piece golf ball is one step up from the 1-piece golf ball. It provides a little more variety to your game.

It is constructed from a solid rubber core surrounded by an exterior cover produced from either Surlyn or urethane.

Beginners that have mastered the basics and want some extra distance will often move onto the 2-piece golf ball. It may fly slightly further than the 1-piece, but the greatest benefit of the 2-piece golf ball is that it rolls out further than any other type of golf ball.

3-Piece Golf Ball

The 3-piece golf ball is suitable for golfers that have a good grasp on their game, and they are often used by some professional golfers. The ball is constructed from a rubber internal core with a second rubber layer around the core. The two layers are then wrapped into an outer cover made from durable Surlyn.

You will experience a softer feel on the clubface and generate more spin. This enables you to exercise more control over the ball trajectory and stopping the ball quicker.

4-Piece golf ball

It is unlikely that the average golfer will take the step up to the 4-piece golf ball. This construction allows for someone to fine-tune their spin control onto the green.

The 4-piece ball consists of a solid rubber core surrounded by two separate layers and a soft urethane outer cover.

5-Piece Golf Ball

The most complex golf ball currently available is the 5-piece golf ball. It is a high-premium ball and generally only used by very advanced or professional golfers. These golf balls are the most expensive on the market.

This ball makes provision for most golf swing styles and velocities with each layer designed to cater for a different shot type.

Distance

The distance that the ball travels could make an enormous difference in your game. When faced with a shorter approach shot you are more likely to get the ball closer to the hole. Golfers that hit the ball enormous distances can be more selective in choosing a ball that does not travel far.

If you do not hit the ball enormous distances, consider a ball that will travel further. Distance should not be your highest priority, rather concentrate on direction and possibly shaping your shots. Once you have control over the ball trajectory improve your distance for those long-awaited eagles.

The higher the compression of the ball the further it will travel when struck well. Lower compression balls produce less spin resulting in more control and straighter shots. The compression of the ball must suit your swing type.

Most golf balls aimed at the average golfers provide less spin and more distance at a very affordable price.

Durability

The durability of your golf ball will be determined by the construction and type of outer layer. Select the ball that will provide you with the characteristics that you require and will last for several rounds. It can become extremely expensive if you have to replace a ball every 9 holes.

Every strike creates some sort of wear on the golf ball especially when a lot of spin is imparted. These marks add up over a round and reduce the effectiveness of the golf ball. The continuous compressing and retracting of the ball impact on the shape causing the ball to move differently to what it was designed to do.

Swing Speed

An essential part of your decision-making process should include the evaluating of your swing speed. There are golf balls that are designed especially for lower swing speeds and others to cater for a variety of swing speeds.

Understanding the speed of your swing will enable you to make an educated decision when finalizing the ball that you want to play with.

Technology

Advanced technology is being used in almost every golf ball on the market. Many manufacturers have experimented with the shape of the dimples on the outer layer in search of the ultimate in distance and control. The technology that goes into the construction of the outer layer improves constantly and enhances the experience and the control of shots especially around the green.

Technology will continue to play a huge role in the distance and control that golfers can impart on every shot

The most suitable golf balls for the average golfer is the 2-piece or 3-piece construction that produces relatively low spin and low compression. This enables you to have more control over your shots and less likely to veer too far off the fairway unless you strike the ball extremely poorly.

The most popular golf balls that provide excellent performance, distance control, and durability will be discussed below.

Reviews of The Best Golf Balls For The Average Golfer

1. Srixon Q-Star

Pros:

  • Urethane cover with spin skin covering produces tour-like feel and spin
  • Long decal with arrow aids in the alignment of putts
  • Tour-level performance at an affordable price
  • Soft compression core produces low driver spin

Cons:

  • It runs out a bit longer on chips

The Srixon Q-Star is a 3-piece, high spin golf ball with a compression rating of 75 aimed at intermediate to advanced golfers. It has an energetic gradient growth core inside a thin Urethane cover and covered with an improved spin skin layer. The urethane cover contains 324 dimples spread out over the ball in the Srixon speed dimple pattern. The dimple pattern creates low drag for enhanced ball flight, longer distance, and more control.

This generates the performance and feel of a tour golf ball and is aimed at golfers with moderate swing speeds.

The Q-star sacrifices some durability for the increase in performance and feel. You will feel like a tour player with the performance you get from this ball. The low compression core controls the spin and golfers with moderate swing speeds will benefit greatly on longer and straighter shots.

2. Srixon Soft Feel

Pros:

  • Affordable quality
  • Extreme consistency
  • Long-lasting and durable provided you do not lose it
  • High ball flight makes it easy to stop on the green
  • Soft feel cover
  • Low spin off driver’s face for straighter longer shots

Cons:

  • Low flying balls do not stop quickly on greens

This is one of the most popular balls for average players providing exceptional feel, distance, and control.

The Srixon Soft Feel is a 2-piece golf ball with a compression rating of 60. It generates medium spin and is ideal for beginners and average golfers.

The Srixon Soft Feel was engineered to produce a highly resilient 71 compression super soft core that gets progressively softer toward the center. This maximizes energy transfer for greater distance and softer feel from tee to green. The low compression delivers a high moment of inertia (MoI) leading to enhanced accuracy on mishits.

The core is covered by a 344 dimple Ionomer cover with an advanced for higher lift force pattern and maximum surface coverage. This reduces the drag and increases ball speed and reduce spin off the driver resulting in the incredible distance, stability, and amazingly soft feel

The great aerodynamics makes the Srixon Soft Feel an ideal partner for a wide range of golfers with low to moderate swing speeds below 90 miles per hour.

Srixon added a unique “hit straight” alignment arrow to aid in the alignment and accuracy on the greens.

3. Callaway Supersoft

Pros:

  • Distance is not a problem
  • Trionomer cover produces a soft feel on short irons, putter, and wedges
  • Soft feel on the putter face
  • Durability is good
  • Extremely well priced and value for money

Cons:

  • Feels too soft on older putters with inserts

One of the most popular golf balls for average golfers is the 2-Piece Callaway Supersoft. The compression rating of 40 makes it one of the lowest compression balls available. The ultra-low compression core promotes fast ball speed and increased accuracy.

The incredibly soft Trionomer cover contains Callaway’s low drag HEX aerodynamics dimples for reduced drag while promoting lift for longer carry distances. The Callaway Supersoft is geared for long and straight shots with a soft feel on the clubhead.

A soft Trigonometry cover formulation keeps the spin rate low making it ideal for the beginner and intermediate golfer without losing the feel and control on and around the green.

4. Snell MTB Black

Pros:

  • Urethane cover is exceptionally durable
  • Excellent spin on approaches and chip shots
  • Provides the feel of a top range golf balls

Cons:

  • Relatively unknown

Snell is a relative newcomer to the golf ball industry but has produced reliable results and has grown quite a following.

The performance of the Snell MTB Black has been top class and they are almost comparable to some of the absolute best in the premium class of balls, at a much lower investment.

The 3-piece golf ball with a compression rating of 80 makes this one of the highest compression ratings in this class.  A fast core lowered the compression rating by 7% from original MTB enables the Snell Black to produce low spin for long distances.

The outer layer design provides the spin control preferred by better players and it reacts very well on the greens.

As a result of the refined aerodynamics, you will experience low lift and low drag enabling you to control the ball flight and less ballooning in the wind.

5. Wilson Staff Fifty Elite

Pros:

  • Great greenside performance
  • Durable and easy to locate
  • Built for distance and ultimate control
  • Great pricing
  • High penetrating ball trajectory

Cons:

  • Durability can be improved
  • The extra distance will be appreciated
  • Not the most premium balls on the market
  • The feel is not the best in class

Wilson produced one of their more popular golf balls for the average golfer as a budget-friendly ball with excellent performance.

The 2-piece ball with a compression rating of 50 produces low spin and is ideal for beginners to intermediate golfers. It is the ideal choice for golfers that want an affordable golf ball coupled with excellent performance

The improved rubber chemistry yields a core that is up to 22% softer than comparable balls. This provides a great balance between long-distance and a soft feel offering you the ultimate in golf ball control.

The outer layer is constructed from a new 302 PhD aerodynamics that features a unique flat bottomed for low air resistance and longer, more accurate shots. Shallow dimples enable the ball to fly through the air to create a more stable, penetrating ball flight.

The extra distance could well place you in range of getting onto the green and closer to the pin for more birdies and eagles.

A new plastic slide pack aids in the durability of the ball and there have been no complaints related to its durability.

6. Titleist Tour Soft

Pros:

  • Exceptionally durable
  • High ball flight for rapid stopping power on the green
  • Large core and the thin outer layer provides a soft feel
  • Low spin off driver’s face for straighter longer shots

Cons:

  • Best for swings under 100 miles per hour
  • More expensive than some of its competitors

Titleist is probably the best-known golf ball manufacturers and their Pro V1 and Pro V1x dominates the professional tours around the globe. Do not fear as they have not neglected aspiring golfers and have produced a wide variety of golf balls to cater to most swing speed and golf swings.

The target market at which it is aimed is the beginner to the intermediate golfer looking for good distance and control.

The new Tour Soft ball is a 2-piece construction with a compression rating of 65, delivering a high spin rate. The ball offers promises a soft feel for longer shots and enhanced spin control.

In the middle, you will find the largest core that Titleist has ever produced. The combination of the extra-large core and the thin outer cover you will experience one of the softest golf balls in this category.

You will notice the extra distance you gain off the tee and the soft feel around the greens.

This is an incredibly good golf ball in this category and can compete with the best of the competitors. However, Titleist is a premium ball producer and priced the ball higher than the most making it less desirable when compared to the best in the class.

7. TaylorMade Project (a)

Pros:

  • Urethane cover gives Tour ball feel
  • Excellent spin on approaches and chip shots
  • High on the list of the money for value contenders

Cons:

  • Urethane cover can scuff easier

The TaylorMade Project (a) is a 3-piece golf ball with a compression rating of 60 and it produces low spin. In the Project (a) TaylorMade released a tour-style ball for average golfers with handicaps between 8 to 18. This is one of the major contenders in the market aimed at average golfers. As your game increases, this ball will enable you to start shaping your shots.

The dual-core design is made up of a larger, softer inner core to remove unwanted spin and enhance the feel. The inner core is covered by a stiffer outer core for increased rebound and velocity.

The outer core reduces spin on your driver and long irons, and it pinches the 322-dimple seamless urethane cover between the clubface for enhancing spin around the greens. Stopping power on the green is comparable to some premium tour golf balls.

8. Bridgestone Golf E12 Soft

Pros:

  • They have a high launch angle
  • Extremely durable

Cons:

  • The distance can be longer
  • Responsiveness on and around the green can be improved

The Bridgestone e12 Soft is a 3-piece golf ball with a Surlyn cover. The high spin golf ball with a compression rating of 50. The design is aimed at a higher launch angle and more carry for intermediate to an advanced golfer with swing speeds below 105 miles per hour.

The enhanced Delta Wing Dimple pattern on the cover creates improved aerodynamics features on Bridgestone’s new Active Acceleration Mantle layer. The mantle comprises a new High-Performance Polymer for increased thrust and higher initial velocity at contact to boost straight distance.

The core is softer providing a more forgiving feel and less spin for an improved long game.

Final Thoughts

Selecting a golf ball for the average golfer is not a straightforward process as many contenders offer remarkably similar qualities and specifications. The ultimate decision will be the one that suits your golf swing and preference. The brand could play a decisive role in unwavering supporters of a specific brand.

There are no poor golf balls amongst the golf balls that we reviewed in this category. Yes, each one has its unique qualities, and some will fly further, some will spin more, and some will feel softer. The one that you will select will be the one that combines the criteria to your liking.

The competition is extremely high and the two golf balls that stood out for me are the Srixon Soft Feel and the Callaway Supersoft. Although they may not be the best in every category, they offer better value for money and all-round performance.

The winner in the category of the best golf ball for the average golfer goes to the Callaway Supersoft by a whisker. Its low compression core and soft outer cover provide the best of both worlds, longer drives, and soft feel around the greens.

Playing the Callaway Super Soft will get you ready to take on those ultra-premium golf balls and not feel out of your comfort zone.

Related Articles